「終わり良ければ・・・」に要注意~チームの結果によって個人の運動学習が左右される~

ad

2026-07-27 北海道大学

北海道大学の阿部匡樹教授らは、サッカーのパスとシュートを模した二人協調課題を用いて、チーム全体の成功・失敗が個人の運動学習に及ぼす影響を実験的に検証した。参加者はパサーとシューターに分かれ、パサーは自身のパス誤差を次の試行で補正する行動を示した。しかし、チームが成功した場合には、失敗した場合より誤差修正量が小さくなり、さらにパスとシュートの誤差方向が一致した場合には修正量が大きくなることが判明した。一方、参加者は自身の誤差を実際より小さく認識していたものの、その主観的評価はチームの成否の影響を受けなかった。これらの結果は、個人の誤差知覚とは独立して、チーム全体の結果や最終的な成果が個人の運動学習プロセスを修飾することを示している。スポーツ指導やリハビリテーション、協調作業の技能学習において、個人の成長を促すフィードバック設計の重要性を示す知見である。

「終わり良ければ・・・」に要注意~チームの結果によって個人の運動学習が左右される~

<関連情報>

個人の誤差応答に及ぼすチームの課題成績の影響 Influence of team task outcomes on individuals’ responses to their own errors

Naoyoshi Matsuda, Haruki Kayukawa, and Masaki O. Abe
Journal of Neurophysiology  Published:Jun 8,2026
DOI:https://doi.org/10.1152/jn.00109.2026

Abstract

In team sports, the consequences of an individual’s action are often decoupled from the team task outcome because teammates can compensate for individual errors. Here, we asked whether in such cooperative contexts, an individual’s learning response to their own error is modulated by team outcome, even when their actions do not directly determine that outcome. We developed a joystick-based cooperative motor task that mimics a final pass and shot in soccer, performed by pairs of human participants (passer and shooter). In error-clamp trials, where the movements of both players did not influence the ball’s trajectory, the ball always deviated by ±6 cm from the pass target (pass error), and the shot either succeeded or failed, thereby defining team outcome. Trial-by-trial changes in the passer’s movement were the hallmark of error-based learning; movements in the subsequent trial shifted in the direction that compensated for the imposed error. Crucially, the passer’s learning response was smaller following success than failure, despite identical pass errors. Furthermore, the learning response was influenced by the directional relation between pass and shot errors. In the evaluation phase, participants judged visual consequences of either action by reporting where the ball crossed a reference line. They underestimated the error (the deviation between the ball and target), which was greater for partner-generated than self-generated errors. However, it was not significantly affected by team task outcomes. These findings suggest that team-level binary outcomes and final errors can modulate motor learning in individuals in a manner that appears dissociable from reportable error perception.

NEW & NOTEWORTHY Binary task outcomes influence error-based learning. Using a joystick-based dyadic task modeled on a soccer pass and shot, we showed that the passer’s learning response to their own pass error was reduced when team task outcome was successful (i.e., the shot was made). These findings indicate that team outcome can modulate individual error-based learning even when one’s action does not directly determine that outcome.

教育
ad
ad
Follow
ad
タイトルとURLをコピーしました