認知症の人における入院加療がその後の死亡率と医療費に与える因果効果を検証―丁寧な入院判断が重要―

ad

2026-06-09 京都大学

京都大学と米国カリフォルニア大学ロサンゼルス校(UCLA)の研究グループは、米国メディケアの約87万件の救急外来受診データを用いて、認知症患者に対する入院加療が死亡率と医療費に与える因果効果を検証した。従来研究では入院患者の予後不良が報告されていたが、重症患者ほど入院しやすいという選択バイアスの影響を十分に除去できていなかった。本研究では、患者が担当救急医にほぼランダムに割り当てられる一方で、医師ごとに入院させる傾向が異なることを利用した「操作変数法」により、バイアスを低減して因果効果を推定した。その結果、入院が救急外来受診後30日および90日時点の死亡率を改善または悪化させるという明確な証拠は得られなかった。一方で、入院により30日間の医療費は平均2,547ドル(約38万円)増加した。研究者らは、認知症患者の入院が不要であることを示したものではなく、入院判断に迷う症例では在宅医療や外来フォローを含む多様な選択肢を慎重に検討する重要性を示唆する成果であるとしている。

認知症の人における入院加療がその後の死亡率と医療費に与える因果効果を検証―丁寧な入院判断が重要―
操作変数法による解析の結果、入院が受診後30日および90日時点の死亡率を改善する、もしくは悪化させるという明確な証拠は得られなかった。一方、入院によって医療費の増加が認められた。エラーバーは95%信頼区間を示す。作成:池洲諒

<関連情報>

認知症患者における入院が医療成果および医療費に及ぼす影響の推定:準実験的研究 Estimating the Effect of Hospital Admission on Health Care Outcomes and Spending Among Persons With Dementia: A Quasi-experimental Study

Ryo Ikesu, MD, PhD, Elizabeth Rose Mayeda, PhD, MPH, Kathleen McGarry, PhD, Roch A. Nianogo, MD, PhD, Christina M. Ramirez, PhD, and Yusuke Tsugawa, MD, PhD
Annals of Internal Medicine  Published:9 June 2026
DOI:10.7326/ANNALS-25-03725

Abstract

Background:

Because transitions in care settings can be confusing for persons with dementia (PWD), hospital admissions can negatively affect their physical and cognitive function. However, the effect of hospital admissions on patient outcomes and health care spending remains largely unknown.

Objective:

To estimate the effects of hospital admissions on health outcomes and health care spending among PWD.

Design:

Quasi-experimental instrumental variable method, using emergency physicians’ admission propensity as the instrument.

Setting:

United States.

Patients:

Medicare fee-for-service beneficiaries aged 66 years or older with dementia who visited an emergency department (ED) in 2017 to 2019.

Measurements:

Death, inpatient days (excluding the index hospital admission), and health care spending (excluding the index ED visit and hospital admission) within 30 and 90 days of ED visits.

Results:

Among 872 085 ED visits (62.9% women; mean age, 83.1 years) included in the analysis, 482 208 (55.3%) resulted in hospital admission. There was no evidence that hospital admission was associated with 30-day mortality rate (adjusted risk difference, −2.6 percentage points [pp] [95% CI, −5.2 to 0.1 pp]) or inpatient days (adjusted difference, 0.1 days [CI, −0.2 to 0.5 days]). Hospital admission was associated with higher 30-day health care spending (adjusted difference, $2547 [CI, $1390 to $3703]). Patterns were similar for 90-day outcomes.

Limitation:

Residual confounding.

Conclusion:

Among Medicare beneficiaries with dementia who visited an ED, there was no evidence that hospital admission was associated with mortality rates. Under conventional statistical criteria, an effect of hospital admissions between a 5.2-pp decrease and a 0.1-pp increase in 30-day mortality rates was highly compatible with the data. On the contrary, hospital admission was associated with higher health care spending.

Primary Funding Source:

None.

医療・健康
ad
ad
Follow
ad
タイトルとURLをコピーしました